2008-2009
Kayli Combs
First Team NAIA-II All-American
First Team WBCA-State Farm NAIA All-American
Academic All-American

Lindsy Murray
Second Team NAIA-II All-American
Honorable Mention WBCA-State Farm All-American

Melissa Duval
Academic All-American

2007-2008
Janessa DeMuth
First Team All-American
Academic All-American
State Farm/WBCA First Team All-American

Kayli Combs
First Team All-American

Lindsy Murray
Honorable Mention All-American

2006-2007
Allison Rader
Academic All-American

Janessa DeMuth
NAIA First Team All-American
Academic All-American

Kayli Combs
NAIA Third Team All-American

2005-2006
Cara Painter
NAIA First Team All-American
Kodak/WBCA First Team All-American
Academic All-American

Janessa DeMuth
NAIA Third Team All-American

2004-2005
Katie Howard
NAIA First Team All-American
Kodak/WBCA All-American Honorable Mention

Renee Garrison
Academic All-American

Amber Melton
Academic All-American

Cara Painter
NAIA First Team All-American
Academic All-American

2003-2004
Renee Garrison
Academic All-American

Katie Howard
NAIA First Team All-American

Cara Painter
NAIA Third Team All-American

2002-2003
Heather Henson
Academic All-American

Mindy Cutbirth
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention

Katie Howard
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention

2001-2002
Regan Hughston
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention

Heather Henson
Academic All-American

2000-2001
Regan Hughston
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention

Susannah Taber
Academic All-American

1999-2000
Amanda Wilson
Academic All-American

Susannah Taber
Academic All-American

1998-1999
Amanda Wilson
Academic All-American

Becky Light
Academic All-American

Seychelle Bruton
Kodak All-American Honorable Mention

Becky Light
Kodak All-American Honorable Mention

1996-1997
Seychelle Bruton
Kodak All-American Honorable Mention

1994-1995
Tara Wilson
Academic All-American

1993-1994
Tara Wilson
Academic All-American

Kristi Chester
Academic All-American

1993-1994
Tammy Eaton
NAIA Second Team All-American

1991-1992
Shawn Turoski
Kodak All-American Honorable Mention

1990-1991
Stacey Fritts
Kodak All-American Honorable Mention